From the IFEX-TMG Report of April 2007:
In past reports of
the IFEX-TMG we observed blocking of
the distribution of books and publications.
We recommended to
the Tunisian government to release banned books, end
censorship, and conform to international standards for freedom
of expression.
At the time of this
latest report we have witnessed no significant change and no
progress on our recommendation.
We therefore
maintain these recommendations and specifically we recommend
to amend Article 8 of the Press Code
by lifting the obligation (for the printer) to deposit copies
of a printed book with the local prosecutor’s office, the
Ministry of the Interior and the chamber of deputies.
The dépôt légal
system is still shamelessly used as a hidden form of censorship
of books in Tunisia. In a country that prides itself on
producing 1,400 titles a year for a population of just over ten
million, there are actually only 200-300 new titles produced per
year; the rest are mainly reprints and children’s books.
Publishers which dare to
publish books the authorities disapprove of not only see these
books being blocked at the printer’s (after having been
printed), but also have to face other forms of harassment,
including forms of fiscal harassment. For more, see the first
IFEX-TMG report.
Three books by Professor
Abdeljelil Temimi, founder of the Temimi Foundation (FTRSI),
have been printed and then blocked through the legal submission
procedure: his book on censorship has been banned since 2000,
and his books on President Habib Bourguiba and on the society of
knowledge since 2003. The national library of Tunisia provides
no reason, nor answer for these bans. In addition, the
distribution of the proceedings of four conferences on
censorship organised by FTRSI are also blocked through the legal
submission procedure. As a consequence, the publication of these
proceedings takes place in another country of the region.
(See: http://www.tn.refer.org/hebergement/temimi/)
In addition, the
distribution of the proceedings of four conferences on
censorship organised by FTRSI are also blocked through the legal
submission procedure. As a consequence, the publication of these
proceedings may take place in another country of the region.
According to the League
of Free Writers (LEL), the situation for book publishing in the
country has worsened since WSIS in 2005. Three examples of
recent book blocking were given:
a.
Portrait of a businessman
who succeeded by Mr. Hamdouni,
Vice-President of LEL. Initially, an authorisation to publish
the novel was issued in November 2006. A few days later, a group
of plainclothes policemen stormed the printer’s in order to
seize the books, which had been printed, and to seize the
receipt authorising the publication. According to LEL, this was
the first time this had happened.
b.
The Rocking Chair
by Amel Mokhtar, a young Tunisian female writer. The second
novel by this author is denied publication and distribution
through the legal submission procedure. The content of this book
is deemed to be too morally controversial. Her first and third
novels are freely available.
c.
Justice
by Falilah Chebbi, a famous Tunisian poet who has published some
20 books. In Justice, she condemns Arab regimes for
spending too much money on armaments, and not enough on social
welfare. The book has been blocked at the printer’s since spring
2006.
In addition, three of
Jalloul Azzouna’s books are still blocked through the
legal submission procedure.
Hafidha Chekir, a member
of the Board of the Tunisian Association of Democratic Women (ATFD),
tried to have her PhD on the role of law in the promotion of
women’s rights published by the University Press (a text for
which she received the Human Rights Prize of the French Society
of International Law), but this was refused. She tried to
self-publish later, but the book was blocked through the legal
submission procedure. Her guide on the participation of women in
political life is also blocked through the legal submission
procedure. It is one of the ten blocked books by the Arabic
Institute of Human Rights.
The proceedings of ATFD’s November 1993
seminar on violence against women are still blocked through the
legal submission procedure.
OLPEC, which issues
reports and alerts whenever it finds out a book is being blocked
through the legal submission procedure, issued a report on the
2006 Tunis Book Fair. The Tunisian authorities issued a list of
banned books in anticipation of the fair. (For more, please see
below.)
Theatre - Khamsoun
Khamsoun (corps otage),
which translates as Fifty, is a play by the famous
Tunisian playwright Fadhel Jaibi. The Tunisian authorities first
refused to issue a permission to show the play. However, after
successfully being performed abroad, including a performance in
Paris, the authorities found no alternative but to allow it to
be performed. This came after six
months of prohibition by the commission of censorship of the
Ministry of the Culture, which had drawn up a list of phrases to
be censored. However, those involved in Khamsoun had
refused to subject the play to this list.
The
play addresses the problems facing Tunisian society after 50
years of independence, including torture in prisons,
fundamentalism and lack of civil and political freedoms. The
play itself became the target of such lack of freedoms as a
result of heavy censorship. The authorities attended the
rehearsals of the play and censored all names of prisons, all
dates and many Quranic verses used in the play. After months of
negotiations, even though the director refused to comply, the
authorities decided to allow the play to run, but only during
the week. The play is not allowed to be performed during the
weekend, and there were few performances in Tunisia in February
2007.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
LIST OF BANNED BOOKS – 2006 TUNIS BOOK FAIR
Source: OLPEC
Books
confiscated from the 2006 Tunis book fair:
|
No. |
Title |
Writer |
Publishing House |
Country |
|
1 |
Lowering the gaze |
Hilal ben Saleh Al Hashemi |
Aljil Al Waed |
Oman |
|
2 |
The role of the mosque |
Saleh ben Salim AL Rabkhi |
|
|
|
3 |
The successful Mission |
Hamad ben Mohammed Al Othmani |
|
|
|
4 |
Reformation of the Nation |
Ahmed
El Khalili |
|
|
|
5 |
How to make your family Happy |
Om El
Warith Al Jamiyya |
|
|
|
6 |
The cups
of the straight way (part1) |
Abul Rabi’ |
|
|
|
7 |
Tears in
the Mihrab of repentance (poetry) |
Om El
Warith Al Jamiyya |
|
|
|
8 |
The
inspirations of the Mihrab |
Ahmed EL
Khalili |
|
|
|
9 |
Dualism
in the Islamic personality |
Ahme El
Khalili |
|
|
|
10 |
Discover
your position |
Ruqayya El
Khrousiyya |
|
|
|
11 |
Word |
Hamad El
Miwali |
|
|
|
12 |
How to
find a wife who can make you happy |
Nourel Din
Ben Ahmed |
|
|
|
13 |
Hymns on
the two (river) banks (poetry) |
Khamis EL
Mikdami |
|
|
|
14 |
Al Imam
Jaber Ben Zaid and the fundamentals of the Ibadhi thought |
Zianah El
Harthiyya |
|
|
|
15 |
Ibadhi
role in the unification of the nation |
Jamila El
Rabkhi |
|
|
|
16 |
Signs of
the hour of Resurrection |
Khalid AL
Wahibi |
|
|
|
17 |
The
efforts of the lessened |
Zahran El
Barashdi |
|
|
|
18 |
Justice |
Ali EL
Hijri |
|
|
|
19 |
The
messages of God |
Aziz Mash-hour |
Dar El
Farqad |
Syria |
|
20 |
Ayman El
Zawahiri |
Jamal Abdul
Rahim |
|
|
|
21 |
The New
Face of Capitalism |
Tawfiq Al
Madini |
Arab
Writers Union |
Syria |
|
22 |
Criticising
the established |
Raja’ ben
Salamah |
Darul Talia’ |
Lebanon |
|
23 |
Partial
secularism and Comprehensive secularism (two parts) |
Abdul Wahab
El Misiri |
Darul
Shorouq |
Egypt
|
|
24 |
The
Sheppard of Souls |
Ibnul
Qayyim Al Jouziyyah |
All
publishers and bookshops |
|
|
25 |
The Soul |
Ibnul
Qayyim Al Jouziyyah |
All
publishers and bookshops |
|
|
26 |
Dictatorship in the modern governing systems |
Ali Khalifa
El kwari |
Wihda
studies centre |
Lebanon |
|
27 |
Prophet-
Khalifa style in modern Arabic political leadership
|
Bashir
Mohammed El Khadra |
Wihda
Studies Centre |
Lebanon |
|
28 |
Arab
Islamic Fundamentalism |
Hussain
Saad |
|
|
|
29 |
Islamic
movements encyclopaedia |
Ahmed EL
Mousili |
|
|
|
30 |
Corruption
and Good Governance |
Debate |
|
|
|
31 |
Fatwa’s
of Abdul Halim Mahmoud |
|
Darul
Maarif |
Egypt |
|
32 |
Arms
possession Low |
|
Legal books
House |
Egypt |
|
33 |
Consensus and will in their unifying dimension |
Rafiq El
Ajam |
Arabic book
House |
Lebanon |
|
34 |
Views of
Fundamentalist Mutazelah |
Ali El
Thwaihi |
Al Rushd
House |
Saudi
Arabia |
|
35 |
Nation,
Society and State |
Radhwa El
Sayyed |
|
Lebanon |
Books examined and allowed:
|
1 |
Perpetual
Conflicts |
Zakaria El
Mahrami |
Promising
generation Publishing House |
Oman |
|
2 |
Security
and Social Thoughts |
Said El
Hitali |
same |
|
|
3 |
The
Quraan and modern challenges |
Mohammed El
Rashid |
The
Pioneers House |
|
|
4 |
The Rise
of Philosophical Thinking in Islam |
Sami El
Nash-shar |
Daarul
Maarif |
Egypt |
|
5 |
Religious
Freedom in Islam |
Abdul
Mitaal Al Seidi |
Daarul
Maarif |
Egypt |
Forbidden Books and
Writers in Tunis Book Fair:
Books:
|
1 |
The
Position of the Quraan from its rivals |
Omar Abdul
Rahman |
Dar masr el
Mahrousa |
Egypt |
|
2 |
Changes
in the Islamic Movement |
Kamal Habib |
same |
|
|
3 |
Islamic
movements- view from inside |
Montaser El
Zayyat |
same |
|
|
4 |
Ayman el
Zawahiri, as I knew him |
Montaser El
Zayyat |
same |
|
|
5 |
Islam and
Politics |
Abdul Elah
Belqziz |
Arabic
Cultural Center |
Morocco |
|
6 |
The first
civilisation war |
Mahdi El
Manjara |
same |
|
|
7 |
The
Future of Political Islam, American point views |
Ahmed
Yousef |
same |
|
|
8 |
Islam and
Politics |
Hasan El
Turabi |
Daarul Saqi |
London |
|
9 |
Political
terminology Dictionary |
Hasan El
Turabi |
Daarul Saqi |
London |
|
10 |
Ibno
Taymiyya (all titles) |
|
All
publishers |
|